What Do Cardinals Eat and How to Attract Them
Backyard Birding , Attracting Birds , Feeders & Feed & Houses
This post contains affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I fully support or use myself. My full terms
Contents
Northern Cardinals eat mostly seeds and wild fruit. Insects fill in the rest, and their share jumps in late spring and summer, when cardinals are raising chicks on them.
Standing in the feed aisle right now? Grab black-oil sunflower. When federal wildlife researchers tested feeder seeds in Maryland in the late 1970s, it drew more cardinal visits than any other seed they put out.
Then tuck a bag of safflower away for the day grackles and starlings move in and empty the feeder. Both tend to show little interest in it, which is the whole point of having it.
One catch before you buy anything: cardinals have to live near you. They stay year-round across the eastern and central United States and in pockets of the desert Southwest. West of the Great Plains they're mostly absent, and a feeder in Seattle or Salt Lake City is very unlikely to ever see one.
How to attract cardinals to your yard
Inside cardinal range, a yard needs four things to bring them in:
- Black-oil sunflower in a platform or hopper feeder, with safflower as the backup
- Dense shrubs or evergreens about 10 feet from the feeder, for cover
- A shallow bath for water, about 1 inch deep at the edge and 2 inches at the deepest
- Native fruiting shrubs, plus seedheads and a weedy edge left standing through winter
What cardinals eat in the wild
The numbers here come from a 1908 study by one very patient government scientist. W. L. McAtee of the U.S. Department of Agriculture examined the stomachs of 498 cardinals. (Yes, stomachs. That's how diet studies worked in 1908.) The birds were collected in every month of the year, across 20 states, Washington, D.C., and Ontario, so the numbers cover a full year of eating.
About 71 percent of it was plant food. The other 29 percent was animal, mostly insects.
Weed and grass seeds carried the diet, at about 36 percent of the year's food on their own. That's more than half of everything plant-based. Smartweeds and their relatives turned up in 81 of the birds, foxtail grasses in 51. Put another way, the scruffy, weedy edge of a field is a cardinal's pantry.
Wild grapes beat every other fruit, and it wasn't close. They made up about 12 percent of the whole year's food, and 17 percent from November through April.
Dogwood came in second, and McAtee couldn't let that pass without comment: "Any one familiar with the intense bitterness of these fruits will admit that the cardinal possesses considerable individuality of taste." It may be the most polite way a scientist has ever called a bird weird.
That thick bill is a seed cracker, built to crush hard shells. Grapes get the fussy treatment. Cardinals often peel them and drop the skin.
| Food group | Share of the year's food (1908 USDA study, 498 stomachs) | Examples from the study |
|---|---|---|
| Weed and grass seeds | About 36% | Smartweed, foxtail, sedges, crabgrass, ragweed |
| Insects | About 26% | Beetles, grasshoppers and crickets, caterpillars, cicadas |
| Wild fruit | About 24% | Wild grapes (about 12% on their own), dogwood, blackberries, mulberries, hackberries, sumac |
| Grain | Just under 9% | Mostly waste corn (kernels left in harvested fields), eaten most in January |
| Other animal food | About 3% | Snails and other mollusks (in 112 of the 498 birds), spiders |
| Other plant food | About 2% | Tulip tree and maple seeds, an occasional acorn |
Treat those percentages as a sketch. McAtee's sample leaned heavily on Texas birds and on May, and the study is 118 years old.
How a cardinal's diet changes through the year
May and January look like two different birds. In the 1908 study, animal food averaged 78 percent of the diet for the 123 birds collected in May and just 5 percent for the 41 collected in January.
Early spring finds them on the ground, foraging for wild seeds. Once the leaves open, they move up to work trees and shrubs for buds and insect larvae.
By fall, fruit takes over. During the fall molt, when old feathers drop and new ones grow in, Linville and Breitwisch watched 30 male cardinals feeding in Ohio for a study published in 1997. And there are the wild grapes again, at about 31 percent of the feeding they observed. Fruit of all kinds came to about 58 percent.
Winter runs on weed seeds, which reach their peak share of the diet then, along with dried berries pulled off the vines.
After the fall molt, many cardinals turn social and travel in loose flocks, anywhere from a handful of birds to a dozen or more.
Many people called the cardinal the redbird in 1908, and that's the name McAtee used when describing its winter habits: "When winter's snows cover its favorite feeding grounds the redbird becomes bolder and seeks its fare about sheds and barns and even among the horses' feet."
Swap the barns for a back porch and McAtee could be describing your feeder in January. Winter is also when feeders draw them in most easily. At one Kentucky feeding station the birds sorted themselves out by rank, with males winning out over females and adults over young birds.
What baby cardinals eat
Young cardinals eat mostly insects. Parents carry beetles, caterpillars, grasshoppers, and cicadas to the nest, and in one small early sample of four young birds, about 95 percent of the food was animal.
That holds for chicks still in the nest, called nestlings, and for fledglings, the young birds that have left the nest but still depend on their parents.
The male stays busy through all of it. He feeds the female while she incubates, helps feed the nestlings, and often takes over the fledglings once she starts the next nest.
Feeding doesn't stop when the young leave the nest, either. Parents keep at it for roughly a month afterward, and all that time the young are eating insects. To a cardinal parent, the caterpillars chewing holes in your shrubs are baby food. A yard that raises cardinals needs them, which means plants that feed caterpillars and no insecticide.
Did a young bird turn up on the ground near your feeder? Read what to do if you find a baby bird before stepping in.
Why a cardinal's red depends on its food
A cardinal's red starts in its food, and the bird does the chemistry. The color comes from carotenoids, the yellow, orange, and red pigments found in fruit and insects, and cardinals can only get them by eating them.
During the late-summer and fall molt, as new feathers grow, cardinals take in yellow carotenoids and convert them to red.
Even captive males fed only seed, with yellow pigments and none of the red ones, still grew red feathers.
Their red came in paler and less saturated than a wild bird's, though. Those captive birds went without fruit and insects, which are rich in carotenoids.
For a backyard, all of this points to plants. Can a feeder seed make a cardinal redder? None has been shown to, while fruiting native shrubs supply the pigment.
The occasional yellow cardinal at a feeder is a rare variant, most likely carrying a genetic glitch that blocks the yellow-to-red step. (If one ever turns up at yours, grab the camera.)
None of this touches the black face mask, which is melanin, a separate pigment that doesn't depend on diet.
Where cardinals live (and where they don't)
Because cardinals don't migrate, the ones at your feeder in July are generally still around in January.
The core range takes in the eastern and central United States and southeastern Canada. Birds are most numerous in the Southeast, and to the west the range thins out across the Great Plains, from southeastern South Dakota down to Texas.
Past that, cardinals are mostly absent from the Pacific Northwest, the Great Basin, most of the Rocky Mountain states, and most of California.
The big exception is the desert Southwest. A separate population lives in mesquite, desert washes, and streamside thickets across central and southern Arizona and southwestern New Mexico, while the main range reaches into southeastern New Mexico and parts of west Texas.
Hawaii is its own story. Cardinals were released there starting in 1929 and now live on all the main islands, and introduced populations also live around Los Angeles and in Bermuda.
For well over a century, cardinals have been pushing north. Massachusetts got its first known nest in 1958, Vermont in 1962, and Maine in 1969, well within living memory.
Scientists credit three changes working together: shrubby suburbs, milder winters, and possibly winter bird feeders. Nobody has yet settled how much each one counts, but your feeder may be part of the push north.
Which side of that line is your yard on? Check which birds visit yards near your ZIP code before planning a feeder around cardinals.
The best food to put out for cardinals
Start with black-oil sunflower, the all-black sunflower seed with a thin shell and a high-fat kernel.
The case for it comes from feeder tests that A. D. Geis ran in Maryland for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service from 1977 to 1979. Of every food on offer, black-oil sunflower drew the most cardinal visits.
It didn't win by much. Black-oil beat black-striped sunflower by about 1.14 visits to every 1, gray-striped drew about two-thirds as many as black-striped, and after that, interest dropped off fast. So if the store is out of black-oil, the black-striped bag will do nicely.
White millet pulled about one-fifth as many cardinal visits as black-striped sunflower. Cardinals will eat peanuts, but when peanut kernels were set next to black-striped sunflower, they drew only about 7 visits for every 100 at the sunflower.
Cracked corn did no better, and Nyjer drew almost none.
The shopping list for a cardinal feeder is short, then. A bag of plain black-oil sunflower seed sold for wild birds is all it takes to get one going.
| Food | How cardinals responded | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Black-oil sunflower | Most visits of any food tested (Maryland, late 1970s) | Your main cardinal seed |
| Black-striped sunflower | A close second in the same tests | A backup when black-oil runs out |
| Safflower | Eaten readily, but not part of the 1970s tests | Fewer grackles, starlings, and House Sparrows, some of the time |
| Hulled sunflower (sunflower hearts or chips) | Eaten | No hulls to rake up, but it spoils fast, so offer a day or two's worth |
| White millet | About one-fifth the visits of black-striped sunflower | Low priority for cardinals |
| Peanuts, cracked corn, nyjer | Far fewer visits than sunflower | Low priority if cardinals are the goal |
| Seed-blended suet | Occasional visits | A cold-weather extra |
Safflower, and what it does and doesn't keep away
Safflower has a thick shell that some birds struggle to crack, and cardinals eat it readily. The Maryland tests left it out, which means they can't say where it ranks.
What it offers is a way to thin out the company. Grackles, starlings, House Sparrows, and squirrels often show less interest in safflower, though some of them learn to eat it.
Doves eat it as well, and the guide to what Mourning Doves eat at the same feeders covers them.
The downside is that most feeder birds prefer sunflower, and black-oil sunflower is the seed that won the measured tests. Switching can shrink the crowd, but it also means giving up the proven winner.
When grackles or starlings start emptying the sunflower, try a bag of plain safflower seed in its own feeder, or switch over completely.
Feeders that suit cardinals
Since cardinals feed mostly on the ground or in low bushes, platform feeders, sometimes called trays, and hopper feeders suit them best. Large tube feeders work too.
A platform feeder is just an open tray. You can hang it, mount it on a post, or set it near the ground, and it draws a wide variety of birds. A basic platform feeder for wild birds is an easy first choice.
Rain and droppings land right in the seed, which is the open tray's weak spot.
A screened bottom that lets water drain helps on any tray. Put out only a couple of days' seed at a time, and wash the tray every couple of weeks.
Expect company. Raised platforms also suit grosbeaks, Blue Jays, and most finches, and it's worth knowing what Blue Jays eat at the same feeders.
In a hopper, seed sits in a covered box and slides down to a feeding ledge as birds eat. A hopper feeder for wild birds gives you a second style to try.
Cardinals should find almost any feeder inside their range. If yours sits untouched anyway, that's a job for the guide on getting birds to find a new feeder.
Where to put a cardinal feeder
Aim for about 10 feet between the feeder and the nearest dense shrubs or evergreens. At that distance a cardinal can make a quick dash to cover, and a cat hiding in the branches is too far away to ambush it. Keeping cats indoors helps too.
How much closer can it go? Not much, since squirrels can leap to a feeder less than 10 feet from a tree or building. So 10 feet is a compromise between the cat and the squirrels.
On a pole, add a baffle below the feeder, a cone or tube that climbing squirrels can't get past, such as a wrap-around squirrel baffle for feeder poles.
There are more tactics in the guide to keeping squirrels off your feeders, and anyone still shopping for a pole can read up on choosing a sturdy feeder pole.
Windows are trickier. Can a feeder make strikes more likely? A single study that followed 43 houses in Edmonton, Alberta, logged nearly twice as many window strikes while a feeder was up. That's one study in one city, but it's enough to plan around.
One fix is to mount the feeder very close to the glass, within about 3 feet, so a bird leaving it can't build up much speed. The other is to treat the glass itself.
Marking the glass is the safest move. The markings go across the outside, no more than 2 inches apart, and the guide on how to keep birds from flying into your windows covers marking options.
What not to feed cardinals, and how to keep feeders safe
- Bread and table scraps spoil fast and offer poor nutrition.
- Skip salted, sugared, or seasoned nuts.
- Wet, moldy, or clumped seed goes in the trash, since some molds make toxins you can't see.
- Raw suet goes rancid in warm weather and can coat feathers, so save it for cold days.
- Skip insecticides in the yard. Pesticides appear in federal wildlife-health records as causes of cardinal deaths, and nestlings depend on insects.
It's nobody's favorite chore, but feeders need cleaning every week or two, and more often in wet weather or under heavy use. Scrub them with soapy water, soak them for 10 minutes in 1 part bleach to 9 parts water, then rinse and let them dry.
Rake up the hulls and droppings underneath as well, because salmonella spreads at crowded feeders when droppings get into the food. During an outbreak, one state wildlife agency advises taking feeders down for two to three weeks.
Water for drinking and bathing
Cardinals drink and bathe year-round, winter included (a bracing thought in January). In dry country, access to water may even shape where they can live.
Keep the bath shallow, about 1 inch deep at the edge and 2 inches at the deepest.
It belongs near shrubs or trees, with a few feet of open ground between the bath and any thick cover where a cat could lurk. Don't set it under the feeder, and change the water every day or two.
A heated bath helps in freezing weather but isn't essential. Plug it into a GFCI outlet, the kind with test and reset buttons, and never use antifreeze or glycerin.
For a ready-made option, there's a heated birdbath for freezing weather, and the guide to choosing a birdbath, including heated ones covers more styles.
The rest of a cold-weather setup, food and shelter included, is in helping backyard birds through winter.
What to plant for cardinals
Plants provide seeds, fruit, or nectar, and support insects. They provide shelter and nesting grounds. That's what the bird came to your garden or patch for.
With cardinals, that comes down to fruit, seeds, and the insects their young need, along with dense shrubs for nests and evergreens for winter cover.
A little mess helps. Since weed seeds were the biggest food group in the 1908 study, seedheads and a weedy edge left standing through winter count as cardinal food. Consider it permission to put off part of the fall cleanup.
Choose native plants, meaning species that occur naturally in your region, and skip invasive ones, the imported plants that spread into wild areas and crowd out natives.
You can find native plants for birds by ZIP code for a closer match to your yard.
Getting started with native plants for birds covers the basics for anyone new to native gardening, and the guide on making your whole yard more inviting to birds takes the whole-yard view.
The lists below cover only places where cardinals live. If your yard is outside that range, the ZIP tool above will point you to plants for the birds you do have.
Northeast and Mid-Atlantic
Maine to Virginia and West Virginia:
- Wild grapes such as summer or riverbank grape, plus frost grape from New Jersey and Pennsylvania south, for fruit, nest tangles, and bark strips for nests
- Flowering dogwood for fall fruit and nest sites, though a fungal disease called dogwood anthracnose is blamed for a decline from New England to Virginia
- Serviceberry for early-summer fruit
- Native blackberries and black raspberry for fruit and brier thickets
- Eastern redcedar and other native conifers for nest sites and winter cover. Keep redcedar away from apple trees, since it hosts cedar-apple rust.
- Native sumacs, such as staghorn and smooth, for fruit that lasts into winter. They spread by root suckers, so give them room.
- American holly on the coast south of Cape Cod, for winter fruit and cover. Berries need a male and a female plant.
Southeast and Gulf Coast
North Carolina to Florida and Louisiana, plus Tennessee, Kentucky, and Arkansas:
- Muscadine and other wild grapes for fruit and nest tangles
- American beautyberry for fall fruit, everywhere here except Kentucky
- Flowering dogwood for fruit
- Sugarberry (Celtis laevigata) for fruit
- Native blackberries and southern dewberry for fruit and brier thickets
- American holly for winter fruit and evergreen cover, with a male and a female plant
- Native red mulberry (Morus rubra) for summer fruit. Buy that exact species, since invasive white mulberry crosses with it.
Midwest and Great Lakes
Ohio and Missouri north to Michigan and Minnesota:
- Wild grapes such as riverbank or summer grape, plus frost grape outside Minnesota and Wisconsin, for fruit and nest tangles
- Common hackberry (Celtis occidentalis) for fruit
- Roughleaf dogwood for fruit, thickets, and nest sites, except in Minnesota, where it isn't native
- Native hawthorns for thorny nest sites and fruit. Skip the introduced oneseed hawthorn.
- Black raspberry and Allegheny blackberry for fruit
- Eastern redcedar and native conifers for nest sites and winter cover, with redcedar kept away from prairie and apple trees
- Serviceberry for early-summer fruit
Great Plains and Texas
The eastern Great Plains, from southeastern South Dakota south through Kansas, Oklahoma, and most of Texas:
- Sugarberry in the south or common hackberry in the north, for fruit
- Roughleaf dogwood for fruit and thickets
- Native wild grapes such as riverbank and summer grape, or mustang grape in Texas and Oklahoma, for fruit
- American beautyberry in east Texas and Oklahoma, for fall fruit
- Honey mesquite where it's native, in Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas, for nest sites and thorny cover
- Native sumacs, such as smooth sumac and skunkbush, for winter fruit. They spread into colonies, and smooth sumac creeps into prairie.
- Common sunflower, a native annual, for seeds. Leave the heads standing.
Next to native grassland, skip new eastern redcedar, which spreads into prairie when fire is kept out. Mesquite has invaded overgrazed grassland as well.
Desert Southwest
This is for the separate desert population in central and southern Arizona and southwestern New Mexico. Cardinal plant use is least studied there, so these picks lean on nest cover:
- Native mesquite for nest sites and cover
- Desert hackberry for fruit and thorny cover
- Netleaf hackberry along washes and streams, as a nest tree
- Native wild grapes such as canyon grape, for fruit
- Common sunflower for seeds
Shrubs that make good nest sites
The female builds the nest, an open cup wedged into a fork deep inside a dense shrub, vine tangle, or small tree, usually about 3 to 10 feet up. The male tags along and sometimes brings material.
A southern Michigan survey of 334 nests found the most in hawthorns, at 21 percent, with dogwoods close behind at 19 percent. Both turn up in the regional lists above, so one planting can do double duty as food and nest site.
A clutch runs 2 to 4 eggs, occasionally 5, and the female incubates them for about 11 to 13 days. The young leave the nest about 9 to 11 days after hatching.
In a good season a pair can raise two or even three broods. Many raise one or none, and because most nests are lost to predators, pairs keep renesting.
Forget the birdhouse. Cardinals build open cups in thick shrubbery, so a dense native shrub does more for them than a box ever will.
Plants to skip, even though cardinals use them
Cardinals eat the fruit of several invasive shrubs and nest in them heavily. In one Ohio sample, 65 percent of 121 nests sat in honeysuckle or multiflora rose.
Does nesting in those shrubs cost cardinals anything? That's still debated.
In central Ohio, Borgmann and Rodewald followed 188 Northern Cardinal and American Robin nests for a 2004 study and found that in urbanizing areas, nests in those shrubs were about twice as likely to be lost to predators. A southwestern Ohio study, though, found shrub type made no difference.
Either way, their invasiveness alone is reason enough to skip bush honeysuckles and multiflora rose. The same goes for these:
- Autumn olive, often recommended because cardinals eat its fruit
- Callery or Bradford pear, with native serviceberry as the swap
- Burning bush
- Japanese barberry
- Privets
- Common and glossy buckthorn
- White mulberry, which crosses with native red mulberry
- Japanese honeysuckle
- Nandina, or heavenly bamboo, whose berries were linked to a Cedar Waxwing die-off in Georgia in 2009, and which is toxic to pets
Pokeweed is native, and cardinals eat the berries, but every part of the plant is poisonous to people and livestock. Don't plant it.
Once the right shrubs are in, the interesting part is seeing which ones your cardinals actually use.
The Bird Garden Journal
A 157-page printable garden journal so you can start growing a yard birds love to visit. You plant things, birds turn up, and it's mostly a lovely blur. This gives you an easy way to start noticing which plants they're using, so next season you can plant more of what worked. Instant digital download.
Get the Journal →Cardinal food and feeding FAQ
What is a cardinal's favorite food?
At feeders, it's black-oil sunflower, which drew the most cardinal visits of any seed when federal wildlife researchers tested feeder foods in Maryland in the late 1970s.
Wild cardinals lean on weed and grass seeds, the biggest share of the diet in the 1908 USDA study, with wild grapes as the top fruit.
Do cardinals eat apples?
Apples aren't a regular part of the wild diet. An early naturalist did report cardinals eating apple seeds, but the 1908 USDA study judged that habit rare, and none of its 498 stomachs held cultivated fruit of any kind.
Some feeding guides suggest a cut apple as an occasional feeder extra, and cardinals may take it.
Do cardinals recognize the people who feed them?
No study has shown that cardinals do. Northern Mockingbirds and magpies, for comparison, can learn individual people who threaten their nests.
One Virginia research team found that male cardinals in cities let people approach closer than rural males did. What looks like attachment is most likely cardinals getting used to people and a daily routine. If you fill the feeder at the same time every morning, that routine is you.
What time of day do cardinals visit feeders?
All day long. They're often among the first birds at feeders in the morning and among the last before dark, and over 15 spring days at one New York feeder camera, cardinals were the likeliest of eight species to still be around at 7 p.m.
Why do cardinals attack windows and car mirrors?
To a cardinal, its reflection in a window, car mirror, or shiny bumper is a rival on its territory. Males and females both do it, mostly in spring and early summer, and it usually stops within a few weeks.
It looks alarming but rarely hurts the bird. On a window, cover the outside of the glass to break the reflection, since coverings on the inside don't work. On a car, fold the mirror in, cover it, or slip a paper bag over it.
Do cardinals mate for life?
Not always. Pairs often stay together through winter and into later years, but some split up between seasons. To see how cardinals compare with other species, read which birds really mate for life.
Stitch a cardinal for the tree
The Christmas Bird Ornaments pattern puts a Northern Cardinal in a pine wreath, alongside a chickadee, nuthatch, titmouse, Blue Jay, and goldfinch. Stitch them onto felt and hang them, or add one to a stocking.
